We understand the importance of cost-effective plan management. However, research indicates that many companies are overpaying for their 401k administration fees.
Overpaying potentially erodes retirement savings for their employees, and certainly erodes corporate profitability, as most Corporate Sponsors pay 401k administration costs. By analyzing industry data and fee structures, we gain insights into the prevalence of overpayments and explore strategies to mitigate this issue.
Prevalence of Overpayments
A study by the Investment Company Institute found that the average all-in fee for 401k plans is around 1% of assets under management. However, a significant portion of plans, particularly smaller ones, pay substantially higher fees. According to the same study, plans with less than $1 million in assets pay an average of 2.22% in fees, while plans with over $1 billion in assets pay an average of 0.38%.
This discrepancy in fees is further highlighted by a report from the Center for American Progress, which found that small plans (under $100 million in assets) often pay fees ranging from 1.5% to 2%, with some plans paying over 2%. In contrast, large plans (over $100 million in assets) almost uniformly have fees below 1%, with the largest plans typically below 0.5%.
Breakdown of 401k Fees
To better understand the potential for overpayments, it's essential to examine the different components of 401k fees. These fees can generally be categorized into three main types:
1. Investment Fees: These fees, which include expense ratios, sales loads, and other investment-related costs, typically make up the largest portion of 401k fees. They are charged as a percentage of assets invested in each fund.
2. Plan Administration Fees: These fees cover the costs of recordkeeping, accounting, legal services, and other administrative tasks associated with managing the 401k plan. They may be charged as a flat fee or a percentage of assets.
3. Individual Service Fees: These fees are charged for optional services, such as taking out a loan or rolling over assets to an IRA.
Strategies to Mitigate Overpayments
To address the issue of overpayments, employers and plan sponsors can consider the following strategies:
1. Conduct regular fee benchmarking: Regularly compare the fees charged by your plan provider against industry averages and competitors. This can help identify potential areas for negotiation or the need to switch providers.
2. Leverage plan size: Larger plans often have more negotiating power and can demand lower fees from providers. Employers can explore opportunities to pool resources with other companies or organizations to increase their bargaining power.
3. Optimize investment menu: Carefully evaluate the investment options offered in your plan and consider replacing high-cost funds with lower-cost alternatives, such as index funds or institutional share classes.
4. Enhance fee transparency: Ensure that all fees are clearly disclosed to participants, enabling them to make informed decisions about their investments and potentially exert pressure on plan sponsors to negotiate better terms.
5. Seek professional guidance: Consider engaging the services of an independent investment advisor who is a legal Fiduciary. Legal fiduciaries can provide unbiased advice on fee structures and help negotiate better terms with plan providers.
By implementing these strategies and staying vigilant about fee structures, employers and plan sponsors can potentially reduce overpayments, maximizing the retirement savings of their employees, increasing corporate profits, and ensuring the long-term success of their 401k plans.
*Submit your question via our inquiry form. We will answer every question in a timely manner.
Comments